You are here

Coalition Letter to Governor Cuomo to Withdraw RD SGEIS

November 2, 2011

Honorable Andrew M. Cuomo
Governor of New York
The State Capital
Albany, NY 12224

Dear Governor Cuomo:

We, the undersigned, strongly support safeguarding the environment, public health, natural resources and scenic splendor of New York’s Catskills, Finger Lakes and Southern Tier regions. With that goal in mind, we request that you immediately withdraw the Marcellus Shale revised draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (RD SGEIS) in order to resolve the fundamental shortcomings documented herein.

There is a de facto moratorium on horizontal hydrofracturing in New York’s Marcellus Shale pending adoption of a Final SGEIS. The Department of Environmental Conservation’s (DEC) 2009 Draft SGEIS received such withering criticism that Governor Paterson signed Executive Order No. 41 requiring DEC to: “make such revisions to the Draft SGEIS that are necessary to analyze comprehensively the environmental impacts associated with high-volume hydraulic fracturing combined with horizontal drilling, ensure that such impacts are appropriately avoided or mitigated …” On 1/1/11, you signed a “continuation” of that Order.

The RD SGEIS Must Be Withdrawn Due to DEC’s Failure to Fulfill Executive Order No. 41

DEC’s RD SGEIS fails to fulfill the mandate of Executive Order No. 41. First and foremost, it is based on the erroneous assertion that:

“No documented instances of groundwater contamination are recorded in the Department’s files from previous horizontal drilling or hydraulic fracturing projects in New York. No documented incidents of groundwater contamination in public water supply systems were reported by the NYSDOH central office and Rochester district office... References have been made to some reports of private well contamination in Chautauqua County in the 1980s that may be attributed to oil and gas drilling... The reported Chautauqua County incidents, the majority of which occurred in the 1980s and which pre-date the current casing and cementing practices and fresh water aquifer supplementary permit conditions, could not be substantiated because pre-drilling water quality testing was not conducted, improper tests were run which yielded inconclusive results and/or the incidents of alleged well contamination were not officially confirmed.”

This statement is factually incorrect and deliberately misleading. Hundreds of natural gas and oil drilling, hydrofracturing and related problems have reportedly impacted private water wells, homes and the environment in New York. Those problems are documented by DEC as well as health authorities in Chautauqua, Cattaraugus and Allegany counties.

Ferrugia’s “Well Documented” Drinking Water Problem “Seemingly Related to Gas Well Development”

For example, DEC is well aware that the Ferrugia family near Jamestown, NY has not been able to drink their well water since 2007 after a gas well was drilled approximately 300 feet from their home. Their water is so polluted that their veterinarian even warned them not to allow their dogs to drink the water. Chautauqua County Health authorities determined: “This is a well documented case showing drinking water impacts that are seemingly related to gas well development.” Yet, DEC has refused to assist this family.

The Ferrugia’s problem directly refutes the RD SGEIS assertions about gas drilling incidents in Chautauqua County because it: a) occurred relatively recently and is on-going; b) was not prevented by DEC regulatory safeguards or gas well drilling and production improvements; c) is documented by pre-drilling and post-drilling drinking water baseline testing and d) was confirmed by local health officials.

See an interview with Mr. David Ferrugia and extensive documents regarding his water well problem at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ka0QJaKZ4s and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/node/7084

Dave Eddy’s Confirmed Drinking Water Contamination in Andover, NY

The Ferrugias are not the only New Yorkers who reportedly were impacted by inadequate regulation of gas drilling. Mr. Dave Eddy and his family experienced drinking water contamination and gas intrusion into their home, reportedly due to hydrofracturing of nearby gas wells. His water pollution was confirmed by the gas drilling firm. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/videos/andover_independenc... and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/allegany_us_ener...

Recently Reported Natural Gas and Oil Spills Further Document DEC’s Regulatory Shortcomings

DEC's hazardous materials spills database identifies hundreds of on-going failures to clean up oil and gas drilling pollution impacts, including at least 72 recently reported natural gas and oil concerns. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/jamestown/group1... These problems further document DEC’s regulatory enforcement shortcomings. For example:

LITTLE WELL - EAST SULLIVANVILLE ROAD HORSEHEADS, NY, 6/23/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 200 gallons. “APPROX 200 GALLONS OF BRINE WATER TO GRAVEL AT WELL SITE. THE SPILL WAS THE RESULT OF A LEAK IN A PORTABLE STORAGE TANK.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

STOSCHEK WELL - 49 BECKHORN HOLLOW ROAD VAN ETTEN, NY, 3/8/2010: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 756 gallons. “VALVE ON THE BRINE TANK FROZE AND BROKE. ALLOWING ABOUT 18 BARRELS OF BRINE TO LEAK OUT.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

POYSA WELL #E1 - 61 BRIGGS HILL ROAD VAN ETTEN, NY, 4/8/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 693 gallons. “Valve on brine tank at closed-in well froze and cracked allowing a release of 16.5 barrels of fairly fresh brine.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

GRUNERT NO. 1 WELL – SOUTH MAIN STREET EXTENSION [?], NY NO ZIP PROVIDED, 6/1/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – CRUDE OIL – 200 gallons. “LEAKING ABOVEGROUND PLASTIC TANK THAT’S INVOLVED WITH GAS WELL.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

TUSCARORA BRINE APPLICATION – TOWN OF TUSCARORA DIRT ROADS TUSCARORA, NY, 6/21/2010: DELIBERATE – BRINE. “Caller states Town is using brine from gas wells to control dust on dirt roads and are applying it way too heavy causing runoff to ditches and streams. Also concerned about his well and what might be in the brine.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

A total of more than 400 historic natural gas and oil concerns are documented by DEC and local health authorities. These concerns refute DEC’s assertion that gas extraction problems do not exist: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/jamestown/CCDOH-... and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/drilling_spills_profiles

At Least 16 Additional Reasons Why the RD SGEIS Must be Immediately Withdrawn

In addition to the regulatory enforcement problems noted above, the RD SGEIS must be immediately withdrawn and sent back to the drawing board because it does not resolve key concerns voiced by Region 2 of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), academic researchers, citizens and local officials. It fails to:

1. Afford equal health protection to all New Yorkers living above the Marcellus Shale formation. The RD SGEIS proposes to ban Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing in the New York City and Syracuse watersheds and above State Lands and primary aquifers (at least temporarily). If horizontal hydrofracturing is not allowed in those areas, it cannot be considered “safe” for other areas of New York.

2. Resolve mortgage lending problems associated with gas leasing. The RD SGEIS ignores gas leasing impacts on mortgage lending documented by lenders, including lender reluctance to secure mortgage loans with properties with gas leases; concerns about property valuation and marketability; "set-back" issues regarding the sale of mortgage loans on the "secondary" market and potential voiding of title insurance. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/alerts/natural-gas-leasing...

3. Assess horizontal hydrofracturing conducted at the same well pad in both Marcellus Shale and underlying Utica Shale. The RD SGEIS does not address this potential practice, but EPA views it as a matter of grave concern. See: http://toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/map-email-responses-...

4. Ban gas drilling wastewaters from being discharged into Publicly Owned Treatment Works designed for sanitary waste or adopt strict pretreatment standards. POTWs are not designed, constructed or maintained to remove or break down the high levels of Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), toxic petroleum constituents and radionuclides documented in gas drilling wastewater. EPA reports that shale gas extraction wastewater contaminants may "'pass through' the POTW, causing the POTW to violate its permit, cause 'interference' with the POTW's operation, or contamination of biosolids..." Pennysylvania has banned this practice. EPA has just begun the process of adopting national pretreatment standards for gas drilling wastewaters. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/letters/2011/06/...

5. Ban toxic gas drilling wastewater from being recycled as hydrofracturing or drilling fluid. Gas drilling wastewaters, including "flowback" as well as "brine" or "produced water," are currently exempted from “GA” effluent limitations designed to safeguard drinking water drawn from the ground in New York. The RD SGEIS fails to eliminate this exemption even though gas drilling wastewater is documented to contain up to 413,000 parts per million of TDS, 72,600 parts per billion of Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons in the diesel range as well as benzene up to 660 parts per billion. Those pollutant concentrations would vastly exceed applicable GA effluent limitations. For example, benzene is only allowed at one part per billion in permitted groundwater discharges.

6. Ban land-spreading of toxic gas drilling wastewaters. DEC allows gas drilling brine to be spread on land for dust control, roadbed stabilization and melting ice and snow. EPA recommended: "A program must be implemented to properly manage the elevated radionuclide concentrations in the brine to protect the worker health, public health, and the environment." The practice of gas drilling wastewater spreading must be halted.

7. Resolve inadequate DEC staffing problems. The infamous memo that caused DEC Commissioner Grannis to be fired noted: "Many of our programs are hanging by a thread. The public would be shocked to learn how thin we are in many areas;" The memo further noted: "While the risks to human health have already increased due to cuts to certain environmental quality programs, and especially to enforcement activities related to pollution sources, further cuts would result in unacceptable risks to New Yorkers and unacceptable liability for New York State government (emphasis added)." Governor Cuomo cut DEC’s budget in 2011. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/dec_dobletter_Grannis...

8. Identify New York areas prone to higher seismic activity and propose measures to prevent earthquakes potentially associated with horizontal hydrofracturing. EPA reported that: "The dSGEIS notes that the State of New York is fairly active seismically. EPA recommends that NYSDEC limit the number of wells in areas of higher seismic activity, or require additional protective measures and monitoring." See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/comments/2009/31...

9. Adopt comprehensive radionuclide standards to safeguard gas drilling workers, public health and the environment. EPA notes that "radionuclide concentrations specified in the DSGEIS represent elevated radionuclide concentrations and need to be handled, managed, and disposed of appropriately to avoid unnecessary exposure to workers, the public, and the environment." EPA also determined that "such concentrations are considered elevated and may pose unacceptable human health risk mainly via external exposure, inhalation of radon and thoron decay products, and to some degree via inadvertent ingestion."

10. Resolve EPA concerns about inadequate protection of Ecosystems and Wildlife. EPA reported: "This section [7.4] is incomplete, and does not account for the changes in the ecosystems in New York State since the preparation of the 1992 GEIS. For example, more animals and plants are on federal and state endangered species lists, habitats of all kinds are more fragmented, invasive species have impacted existing animal and plant populations, and climate change has impacted plant and animal ranges and migrations.”

11. Assess "cumulative impacts" on a comprehensive basis. EPA notes that it is "concerned that cumulative and indirect impacts need to be more thoroughly discussed in the dSGEIS. Even with its generic format, the EIS should discuss the impacts that may result from past, present, and reasonably foreseeable future projects as well as those impacts associated with drilling and hydrofracturing that may occur later in time and/or further from the immediate project site."

12. Update the 1992 GEIS. EPA notes that it is "concerned that over the past 17 years since the 1992 GElS was written, the 'existing' environment and conditions in New York State have changed sufficiently that using the information from that report as a baseline for the dSGEIS will not take into account the cumulative impacts from habitat fragmentation, population increase, and climate change that may have occurred during that time."

13. Require compliance with a critical EPA policy change regarding air quality assessment. Shortly after the draft SGEIS was released on 9/30/09, EPA adopted a major new policy regarding New Source Review (NSR) and Title V permitting programs pursuant to the Clean Air Act. This reversed the EPA policy in effect when the draft SGEIS was prepared. The new policy changes the requirements for "source aggregation" for air permitting programs. According to a DEC Powerpoint slide: "Since level of aggregation must be case by case, SGEIS cannot provide definitive answers (emphasis added)." See: http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2009/10/14/14greenwire-epa-tosses-bush-era-... and http://toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/powerpoint_foil-4pg.pdf

14. Eliminate DEC’s current hazardous waste regulatory exemption for gas drilling wastes and impose strict liability for cleaning up gas drilling pollution hazards.

15. Require the New York State Department of Health to share co-lead agency status with DEC and assess health impacts on a comprehensive basis.

16. Require immediate disclosure of uncontrolled gas drilling pollution releases, establish a dedicated fund to remediate gas drilling hazards and require gas drilling firms to provide financial surety for remediating problems by posting bonds or providing insurance coverage.

Conclusion

The RD SGEIS fails to provide a meaningful plan to safeguard New York from the irreparable harm that could be caused by the vast industrialization associated with Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing. Unless and until DEC resolves its regulatory enforcement problems and addresses the additional concerns documented herein, New York’s de facto moratorium on horizontal hydrofracturing in Marcellus Shale must not be lifted.

We trust that you will find our request self-explanatory. Thank you for your consideration. We look forward to your prompt reply.

Very truly yours,

Total Signatory Count: 22949

Lindsay Battle
250 Brodhead Rd
West Shokan, NY
lisa gorn
county highway 8
morris, new york
Paul Abrams
30 Staples St
Kingston, NY
Eric Glesmann
9732 Starr Hill Rd
Remsen, NY
Steven F Hart
1071 Manor La
Bay Shore, NY
Rand Gartman
51 carolyn drive
cortlandt manor , ny
Kristina Muenzenmaier
31 holly drive
New Rochelle, NY
Judith Cox
316 W. 84 Street, 2C
New York, New York
Lawrence Cummings
10593 West Shelby Road
Middleport, NY
Marc Beschler
5 East 51st Street, #4A
New York, NY
Meg Montgomery
20 Liberty Commons Way
Liberty, NY
diane roffe
po box 101
morris, newyork
Frank Ninivaggi
75 Leslie Ave
Si, ny
T. Ortega
35-91 161st Street
Flushing, NY
Robert Burr
51st ave
LIC, NY
madeline shaw
696 ridgebury rd
slate hill, ny
mary boyle
16 woodside drive
albany, nY
Richard Schultz
3060 rt 44/55
gardiner, ny
Dennis Kulwiec
273 23rd St Apt 2r
Brooklyn, NY
Jacob Blazer
863 Glen Drive
Woodmere, New York
John Kixmiller
1678 8th Avenue
Brooklyn, New York
david reibman
689 columbus avenue
new york, nY
Roberta Jachym
7107 W.South St.
Westmoreland, New York
Jon Gehret
46 Duncott Rd
Fairport, NY
Claire Blazer
863 Glen Drive
Woodmere, New York
Charles Monroe
100 Woodland Drive
Pleasantville, NY
Ira Wechsler
1638 E. 52 street
Brooklyn, NY
Robert Davenport
1975 Collard Rd
Skaneateles, NY
Marilyn Bush
619 Ford Hill Rd.
Berkshire, NY
Joan Walker
19919 24th Road
Whitestone, NY
deb yaro
sampson road
morris, new york
Dan Greenburg
645 N. Broadway
Hastings-on-Hudson, NY
David Poteet
120 Park Street
Canandaigua, NY
Thomas Kearney
415 East 17th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Richard Gundlach
285 Saint Marks Place
Staten Island, New York, NY
Janice Logan RN
Po box 155
South Otselic, Ny
Maxine DeSeta
127 West 120th St
New York, NY
Frank Adams
91-05 102nd St.
Richmond Hill, NY
Kati Meister
------
New York, NY
Howard Barker
141 Collyer Road, Box 113
Smithville Flats, NY
Christine Snyder
512 Roycroft Blvd.
Cheektowaga, NY
Walt Daniels
2802 Deer Street
Mohegan Lake, New York
nina loney
348 snyder hill road
ithaca, ny
Erika Hofmann
104 hawthorne ave
floral park, ny
JK Kibler
PO Box
Ghent, NY
Michael Hanna
21 Lenape rd.
Newburgh, NY
Robert Hanley
180 Delta Rd.
Amherst , New York
Jessica Chapman
46 East Avenue Apt 1
Naples, NY
Judith Long
25 Blanchard Street, Jamestown, nY 14701
Jamestown, NY
Sandra Shear
Heather Hill Drive
West Seneca, New York
jeanne betti
17 marcella blvd
hopewell jct, new york
David DiBlanca
18 Craigville Rd Bldg 16-7
Goshen, NY
Emily Squires
250 West 94th St, 11C
New York, New York
Reisa Gould-Donath
130 East Ave.
Saratoga Springs, New York
Carol Kastendieck
114 Clinton St. 6A
Brooklyn, NY
Thomas Girshin
3543 Ransom Rd
Jamesville, NY
Thomas Matteo
150 West End Ave
New York, NY
TYLER HOUSMAN
318 NORTHERN BLVD
ALBANY, NY
Frank Knobloch
33 Fraleigh Street
Red Hook, NY
Jay Nickerson
2914 Fort Hamilton Parkway, Apt 1-R
Brooklyn, New York
Helen Rogers
476 West 142 Street
New York, NY
Molly Carney
10851 Bohemian Way
Hammondsport, New York
Alicia Williams
710 West 168th ST
New York, NY
Deepti Thomas-paulose
630 West 246th Street
Bronx, NY
adam barbera
p.o. box 434
worcester, new york
Michelle Segre
224 8th Ave.
New York, New York
Kristy King
156 P.A. johns Rd NE
Milledgeville, Ga
daniel polanco
1825 riverside drive
new york, new york
eleni kalfus
2728 Henry Hudson Parkway
Bronx, New York City, NY
Maria Santiago
25 Cumming Street
New York, NY
Lisa Skardinski
3383 LaFayette Rd
Jamesville, NY
Donna Chambers
7641 Merritt Drive
Baldwinsville, NY
stephen whitehead
734 lake rd
king ferry, ny
Marie Hall
1483 Vroom Road
Spencerport, NY
Terry Major
PO Box 342
Skaneateles, NY
Susan Nagel
8 Clay Ct.
Rhinebeck, NY
Ellen Singer
P.O. Box 312
Youngsville, NY
Richard Mennen
997 taughannock blvd.
Ithaca, NY
richard becker
7860 northfield rd
clarence center, ny
Ronald Keller
19 Roberts Rd.
Endicott, NY
Jean Neidhardt
3894 Davis Corners Road
Morrisville, NY
Joe Cleveland
206 Meyers Road
Liverpool, NY
Alla Riley
96-09 67th Avenue, 1D
Rego Park, NY
Glen Widjeskog
23 W PIERPONT ST
KINGSTON, NY
Suellen Tozzi
8 Sycamore Avenue
New Rochelle, NY
Isabelle Garbani
540 79th St
Brooklyn, NY
Lauren Leahy
142 Figurea Ave
Staten Island, NY
Handy Gelbard
6 Widewaters Lane
Pittsford, NY
Mary Loomba
24 Pleasant Ridge Road
Valhalla, NY
Joseph Knapp
43-45 42nd St apt 1d
Sunnyside, NY
Newman T. Baker
274 E. 3rd St. #3
New York, NY
Beth Darlington
124 Raymond Avenue
Poughkeepsie, New York
Erik Peterson
7362 Gulick rd
Naples, NY
Howard Botting
109 Watson Road
North Syracuse, NY
Jude Barnes
269 Sterling Avenue
Buffalo, NY
Elisabeth Youngclaus
15 Jones Street, Apt 3G
New York, NY
Nora Soto
8 Tower Hill Road
Pawling, NY
Jovi Geraci
15 Haven Ct
Nyack, New York
Stefanie Simmons
28 Broadway Ave
Ssaranac Lake, New York
norbert lazar
875 salisbury tpk
milan, ny
Virginia Loughlin
9 Ryder Road
Ossining, NY
Sara Cooley
124 Raymond Ave
Poughkeepsie, NY
Rebecca Utter
6138 State Hwy 41
Smithville Flats, NY
Robert J. Smith
7663 Tackabury Road
Earlville, New York
christine exford
67 mead mtn rd
woodstock, new york
Gabrielle Kayser
2 Pine Street
Hicksville, NY
Gloria Jacobs
399 Washington St. #3
New York, NY
James Doidge
909 Castle Point Terrace
Hoboken, NJ
Almeta Whitis
1400 Plymouth Avenue South Apt. 1017
Rochester, New York
Joann Faberlle
4 2nd Street
Wading River, NY
Paul Jaffe
821C Chestnut Ridge Rd
Chestnut Ridge, New York
Jonathan Stone
507 Grooms Road
Clifton Park, NY
Dorothy Avery
6025 Sautell Road
Bergen, New York
John Neddermeyer
78 Balsam Place
Bronx, New York
Rosemary Clifford
200 Centre Avenue
New Rochelle, NY
Fred Karpoff
612 Bradford Pkwy
Syracuse, NY
Gregg Hamberger
1000 East Avenue #607
Rochester, NY
Genji Siraisi
550 Grand St
New York, NY
Elizabeth Chaney
120 4th Place
Brooklyn, NY
Brian Shumway
165 W. 80 Street # 2D
New York, N.Y.
Joshua Vogt
180 Edgewood ave
Hurley, Ny
Randi Abraham
113 Prospect Park SW
Brooklyn, NY
Ellen Jong
1112 moonlight drive
monticello, NY
Henry Snee
44 West 77th St.
New York, NY
Farrin Anello
.
Sleepy Hollow, New York
Franklin Roth
127 West 96th Street, Apt. 12B
New York, NY
barbara drecker
511 east 82 st.#4fw
ny, ny
Carole Ashley
48 Beach St
New York, NY
Martha Cole
26 Redmond Av
Bay Shore, NY
Paula Poons
831 Broadway
New York, NY
Roberta Young
Crane Ave.
White Plains, NY
Kristina Hamalainen
4244 Betty Brook Road
South Kortright, NY
Beverley Pierson
17 Countryside Rd.
Fairport, New York
William Wilkens
6 Woodhull Ln
Holtsville, New York
E Perrone
4 Brandon RD
Brewster, NY
Linda Larkin
401 East 84th St.
New York, NY
James Richardson
3192 County Hwy 21
Walton, NY
Deborah Goldberg
55 Lake Shore Dr
Copake, N.Y.
tara sullivan
8 Blanchard ave
Binghamton, ny
Synnove Heggoy
43 Mill St.
Dryden, NY
philip barreca
2002 5th ave
nyc, new york
randi halpern
19 obernburg road
obernburg, new york
Douglas Ward
140 Bleecker Street
Gloversville, NY
Kim Keil-DeZarn
3965 spring road east west Sparta ny 14437
West Sparta, Ny
Karen Socolow
2 Charlton St. Apt. 3D
New York City, NY
lionel closson
W 112th Street
New York, NY
Elizabeth Vincent
57 Arlo Road
Staten Island, NY
Kathryn Kassner
362 Fitzsimmons Road
Milan, NY
Neal Madnick
169-10 33 Avenue
Flushing, NY
Arielle Holstein
8138 Old Sunridge Dr.
Manlius, New York
Ms Chris Gordon Owen
902 Union St #2
Brooklyn, NY
Elizabrth Curley
4468 South St
Jamesville, NY
Penelope King
PO Box 15
Meridale, NY
Martha Yoshida
570 Amsterdam Ave #5R
New York , New York
G Barry
14 Boxwood Ct
Huntington, NY
Kathleen Collins
18 Sherwood Ave.
Binghamton, NY
Sandra Neznamy
20 Stuyvesant Oval #8B
New York, New York
Russell Hollander
25 Nelson Road #55
Lake Huntington, NY
Susan Beach
90 Ellis Ave.
Springville, NY
kathryn henderson
box 82
cold brook, ny
Michael Cerasaro
5 Moonwatcher Place
New Paltz, NY
Paul Conlon
80-25 166 Street
Jamaica, NY
Elle Gohl
243 Cream St.
Poughkeepsie, NY
Maryanne Yenoli
212 East 3rd Street
Deer Park, New York
Christa Bissell
137 Pine Tree Rd
Ithaca, NY
Michael Rohrbach
62 Pamela Drive
Binghamton, NY
Jason Blynn
443 1st St.
Brooklyn, NY
Bob Hazen
169 Roby Street
Lockport, ny
Regina Rock
304 Lakeshore Drive
Smallwood, New York
Susan Wells
508 East Fifth Street
New York, NY
Richard Meek
224 N. Beech st.
N. Massapequa, NY
Richard Briggs
747 Broome Center Rd.
Preston Hollow, NY
Sandra Utter
6138 State Highway 41
Smithville Flats, New York
Karen Keating-Secular
6361 99th Street
Rego Park, NY
Janna Herchenroder
192 benninger rd
Delanson, NY
Elaine Karton
72 Henry St
Merrick, ny
Pamela Anderegg
18 Tuxill Square
Auburn, New York
Diana DeZarn
2522 Buttermilk Pk.
Villa Hills, KY
Michelle Carlson
1206 Hollow Road
Clinton Corners, NY
michael d'angelo
38 rumsey road
yonkers, ny
Virginia Wintle
48 Blackberry Drive
Brewster, NY
fred breden
205 buena vista rd
new city, ny
Karen Wieland, Ph.D
82 Jefferson St.
Salamanca, NY
Ieva Liepkaula
416 Elm Ave
Selkirk, NY
Michele Ellis-Porcaro
846 State Highway 11C
Brasher Falls, NY
Rosemarie Byrne
46 Briarfield Lane
Huntington, NY
Robin Perl
72 Berry St.
Bklyn, NY
Joseph Murphy
180 Old Route 304
New City, NY
Penelope Clyne
52 michigan rd
woodbourne, NY
Mary Wheat
45 W Fairview Ave
Valley Stream, NY
Laura Hill
2 Roxbury Ct
Voorheesville, NY
ira ballen
166 east 96 st
new york, ny
Marc Porcaro
846 State Highway 11C
Brasher Falls, NY
George Stadnik
24-66 44 Street
Astoria, NY
Cornelia Farnum
361 White Church Road
Brooktondale, New York
Colleen Upholt
690 Lovell Hill Rd PO Box 640
Marathon, NY
Danette Lipten
153 Bennett Ave Apt 1 E
NEW YORK, New York
Ellen Shapiro
3444 Bay Front Drive
Baldwin, New York
Modris Morozovs
416 Elm Ave
Selkirk, New york
Jamie O'Brien
1751 Second Avenue #16B
New York, NY
Jean Naples
9 Benson Street
West Haverstraw, New York
Vince Natale
18 Van De bogart Road
Woodstock, NY
Elizabeth Clute
1 Jay St
Cohoes, New York
Kelly Chamberlain
2363 Grand Ave
Baldwin, NY
Linda Cali
245 Summit Park Road
Pomona, NY
Steve Sandler
75 Henry Street Apt 16A
Brooklyn, NY
Noreen Stevenson
16 Elm Street
Chester, New York
Priscilla Reynolds
88 Cherry Hill Road
Accord, New York
Holland Gregg
3872 Jordan Road
Skaneateles, NY
Paul Ghenoiu
33 West Hill Rd
Plattsburgh, NY
lois cronk
6189 olmsted rd
chittenango, ny
Sandra Wilson
247 W. 123rd St
New York, NY
J Rosen
400 w 43 street
new york, n.y.
Vicente Martinez
89 Beaver St
Brooklyn, NY
sandra sajonas
100 Maspeth Avenue
Brooklyn, New York
JEFF COSTELLO
164 MANILA AVE
NEW YORK, NY
hortense thurm
1096 sunset st.
yorktown hgts., new york
Sharon Gendreau
3829 Federal Rd.
Livonia, NY
Rosalind Schneider
40 Cottontail Lane
Irvington, NY
Anna Marandi
34th st.
Queens, NY
Joel chaffee
601 morgan ave
brooklyn, NY
Esther Evans
1587 Van Camp Rd.
Skaneateles, New York
davide cantoni
119 henry street #3
brooklyn, ny
Kathy Sajor
41 Trafalgar Dr.
Plattsburgh, NY
eileen johnson
93 St. Marks Place
new york, NY
Paula Ward
PO Box 296
Stanfordville, NY
Amit Regev
396 Tompkins Ave #4B
Brooklyn, NY
Nancy Possenti
315 W. 98th St. #7C
New York, NY
John Survil
PO Box 69
Olean, NY
Maureen Murphy
25 Beckett ct
Chestnut Ridge, NY
Michelle Cronk
188 St. Nicholas Avenue
New York, NY
Steven Handwerker
50 Shultis farm Rd
Bearsville, NY
Susan Hopf
West Walworth Rd
Macedon, NY
willis van dyne
27 hunters run
cohoes, ny
Mike Swensen
149 Frissell Rd
Jamestown, New York
shirley ferguson
134 main st
franklin , ny
Stephen J. Mazurek
850 Center Street #307
Lewiston, NY
Glenon Friedmaan
7 Pine Street
Bar Harbor`, Maine
Thomas Angie
3693 Mill Street
Marion, NY
zoe mackler
57 Front St
brooklyn, ny
Mark Peacock
149 Colonial Rd
Rochester, NY
SueAnne Gershenzon
310 East 46th Street
New York, NY
Elizabeth Falk
175 Leonard RD
Newfield, NY
M. B. Breard
800 Riverside Drive, #8G
New York, NY
Josephine Girardin
27 Reilly Street
West Islip, NY
AnnMarie Taliercio
3461 West Seneca Turnpike
Syracuse , NY
Maxine Krasnow
212 W 105th St
NYC, NY
Andrea Frank
33 Walnut St
Somerville, MA
Benjamin Blum-Smith
27 W. 96th St. Apt. 15F
New York, New York
Louise Bikoff
14 Algonquin Dr
Huntington Sta, NY
Lee Boroson
455 Bailey Road
Stamford, NY
David Latham
400 West 43rd St.
New York, NY
Catherine S Davis
3700 Highland Ave
Skaneateles, NY
Mary Rae Pineo
78 Scott Ave
Elmira, NewYork
Connie Lembaris
5515 County Road 33
Canandaigua, New York
Christine Stanfield
258 West 117th Street, #50W
New York, NY
Lisa Phillips
30 Ocean Parkway Apt.3e
Brooklyn, ny
jane gordon
40 white birch drive
pomona, ny
nanci steeb
73 amsterdam road
rochester, ny
Somdev and Lee Bhattacharji
685 Kelly Road
Arkville, NY
Zuzana Ryznarova
52-07 39th Avenue
Sunnyside, NY
lynda caspe
150 franklin Street
new York, nY
Lee Reich
387 Springtown Road
New Paltz, NY
Lindsay Oakes
3149 Broadway #9
New York, NY
Mary Andreani
7603 County Road 12
Naples, New York
Suzanne Arnold
3530 82nd Street Apt. 41
Jackson Heights, NY
licia stroub
149 Vermilyea Ave
new your, ny
Julietta Eisenberg
43 West 93rd Street #7
New York, N.Y.
Yvonna Balfour
280 Ninth Avenue #17G
New York, NY
Thomas Dodson
118 Coventry Ave
Albertson, NY
Dan Rain
12 Pineridge Place
Delmar, NY
Khy and Link Manuso
2 Fifth Avenue
New York, NY
Yael Hammerman
521 West 122nd St. #42
New York , NY
Valerie LEGEAY
Po Box 37
Staatsburg, New York
Brenda Reiss
20 Dressler Road
Greenlawn, NY
Louis Philips
1046 O'Brien Ave.
Schenectady, NY
NOZ CAVAN
155 E 33 STREET
NEW York, NY
Kat Roberts
101 Summit St
Brooklyn, NY
Carl Bruetsch
40 Lux Road
Cochecton, New York
deb krisanda
34 revere road
scarsdale, ny
phyllis edwards
po box 236
whitney point, NY
Jack Palminteri
1797 County Hwy 50
Cherry Valley, New York
Matthew O'Brian
147 1 st street
Troy, NY
RUTH HYDE
61 Fernboro Road
Rochester, NY
Steve Savitz
111 East 2nd Street #4A
New York, NY
Kathleen Braico MD
10 Ashley Place
Queensbury, New York
Donald Castellow
77 Baer Rd
Callicoon, NY
robyn tauss
5 Angela Court
Beacon, NY
Lina Chen
1931 64th ST.
Brooklyn, NY
Linda Culver
Merritt Hill
Penn Yan, NY
Leathea Vanadore
330 W. 28th Street, 12G
New York, NY
Bobbie Flowers
418 West 17th Street, Apt. 22A
New York, New York
Karen Harding
653 Route 208
Gardiner, NY
Miriam Cooper
11 Warren St
Kingston, NY
Ashley Hughes
PO Box 204
Gilbertsville, NY
Alice and Donald Pulver
19 Cricket Hill Drive
Pittsford, NY
Maureen Russell
251 prospect street
canandaigua, NY
Pamela Stiles
70 Penarrow Rd.
Rochester, ny
Sharon Sachs
84 West Broadway
New York, New York
Felisa Sheskin
949 Ulster Heights Rd.
Ellenville, NY
Susan Goldman
102 Old Farm Rd
Woodstock, NY
Danielle Hedderson
5 Meadowbrook Drive #7
Slingerlands, NY
Virginia Mazzarella
327 Mendon Center Road
Pittsford, NY
Anne Saltman
2175 Ten Eyck Avenue
Cazenovia, New York
Michael Puryear
46 Longyar Rd.
Shokan,, NY
Louise Fraza
236 E 89 St., #3C
New York, New York
Ginaq Elmi
119 Lee Road
Garden City, NY
Timothy Rice
22 Jarvis Drive
Manlius, NY
Beth Mackey
59 Clinton Ave #1
Kingston, NY
Charlotte Podolsky
4 Spring Hollow
Roslyn, New York
David Anderson
185 Claremont Ave. #4e
New York , New York
Keith Baumwald
39 Division Street
New York, NY
pat hovey
PO Box 1305
Southold, NY
Pamela Zaber
1536 Barclay Place
Niskayuna, NY
Ken Filiano
123 Boerum Place #G1
Brooklyn, NY
Richard Wunderlich
210 River Road
Peru, NY
Joyce Kuzemka
33 Holmes Avenue
Apalachin, NY
Stephen Coppola
137 Madison St. #1
Brooklyn , NY
shirley hogg
289 bone plain rd
freeville, ny
Lynnette Hazard
11929 Parker Rd
East Aurora, NY
Bernice Goldstein
4 Sadore Lane
yonkers, NY
Glen Straight
1879 Shuler Rd.
Lyons, NY
Alexander Nagel
110 Bleecker St. Apt 22B
New York, NY
sue keller
84 arlington ave
rvc, ny
Nancy Anderson, RN
2825 Wager Hill Rd
Penn Yan, New York
Chris Kubie
3 Kendall Dr.
Brewste , NY
IRENE PELLED
111 - 10 76 ROAD
fOREST HILLS, NY
Mira Rubens
187 Windsor Place
Brooklyn, New York
Robert Friedman
616 Cherry Rd.
Syracuse, NY
Elizabeth Moran
8 Pin Oak Drive
Kinderhook, NY
Betsy Malcolm
300 Central Park West
New York, NY
Jerry Felix
113 Washington Pl #8
New York, NY
Gail Pickett
118-17 UNION TURNPIKE
FOREST HILLS, NY
Ann Toner
39 Goffredo Court
Middletown, New York
Richard Nurse
54 Reddick Lane
Rochester, NY
Linda Karpell
111 Cherry Hill Rd
Accord, NY
Robert Puca
535 dean street apt.#306
Brooklyn, NY
Margaret Przygocki
6107 Cold Springs Road
Trumansburg, New York
James Davis
68 West Bloomfield Road
Pittsford, NY
Susan Crocker
365 Genesee Park Drive
Syracuse, NY
Jerry Travis
509 W110
New York, NY
Fay Aaronson
1115 East 36 Street
Brooklyn, New York
Peter Maurer
36 Old Barn Circle
Penfield, New York
Robert Shoup
347 Crescent Avenue
Highland, NY
Catherine Bedzyk
20 Landmark Lane
Pittsford, NY
karen long
2882 river road
niskayuna, new york
Robert Fine
126 West Clarkstown Rd
New City, NY
Janis Nori
15 Grist Mill Rd
Tillson, New York
jack doig
doigjf@yahoo.com
Andes, N.Y.
Terri Teeling
494 cooksbobo road
troy, ny
Diana Praus
126 Menand Road
Menands, NY
Marilyn Klaiber
72 Algonquin Rd
Clifton Park, NY
Judith Lasko
175 West 93rd St #16F
New York, NY
Philip Clift
22 South Pollard Drive
Fulton , New York
Mary Anna Jun-Morris
11 Kathy Street
Hampton Bays, NY
saralea chazan
29 washington square west 5B
new york, new york
john clark
35-11 85th Street
Jackson Heights, New York
Bernadette Socha
2308 Almeria Road
Niskayuna, NY
rick tobin
72 rensselaer dr
commack, ny
Elaine Lennox
80 Locust Hill Dr
Rochester, NY
Patricia C Schwarzlander
270 Fenway Dr
Syracuse, NY
Robert Stillson
P.O. Box 341
Bolivar, New York
Frederick Ench
76 Red Hill Road
New City, NY
Anton Stayduhar
PO box 690
Bloomingburg, NY
Peter Eliscu
220 West 98th Street #5G
NewYork, NY
Jeremiah Jordan
17 Red Post Crescent
Fairport, NY
Alison Bentley Walsh
300 Third St.
Liverpool, NY
Lauren Blaushild
16 Aster Drive
Hicksville, NY
Cynthia DeBruin
94 Tuckahoe Avenue
Eastchester, New York
Laura YEDWAB
1 Philson Ct
commack, ny
Patricia Kramer
124 Church Road
Sherburne, NY
marshall page
1599 willowdale rd.
skaneateles, ny
Douglas Cantor
45 S Madison Ave Apt 6A
Spring Valley, NY
Edward Lakatos
120 Truesdale Drive
Croton on Hudson, NY
Eva Burpee
2 Guion Road
Rye, NY
Carl Klein
12377 Big Tree Rd
Wales Center, NY
Sonora Dolce
2530 Radcliff Ave
Bronx, NY
Robert Smeallie
75 Westerlo St
Albany, NY
Kathryn Davis
1229 River Rd.
Troy, NY
Carole Kunstadt
470 West End Avenue 8A
New York, NY
Jill Lewis
1 S. Wheaton Rd
Horseheads, NY
Eleanor Liggio
709 Old Country Road
Elmsford, Ny
Jacob L. Milligan II
175 W 87th St, Apt. 26-G
New York, NY
Adolfo Caldas
1604 Jasmine Avenue
New Hyde Park, NY
Kirk Lawrence
247 Railroad Avenue, Apt B
Sayville, New York
Timothy Bruno
74 Radio Tower Road
Callicoon, New York
Chaim Peskoff
83 Wyckoff Ave
Brooklyn, New York
tom luciano
601 warren st
Hudson, NY
Michael Hollitscher
592 10th Street
Brooklyn, United States - New Jersey
sue glassman
13 Terrace Circle 3H
Great Neck, NY
Bonnie Mion
49 Mill Street
New Baltimore, N.Y.
Margot Steinberg
9 Orchard Streeet
Dobbs Ferry, NY
Linda Grosso
572 Grand St
New York, NY
Kelli Markham Nowakowski
443 Hathaway rd.
Otego, N.Y.
Lynne Saulsbury
103 Landmark Drive
Ithaca, NY
Joe Fastaia
7 Buttonwood Circle
Fairport, Choose a State
Rose Kwiatkowski
Skyline Drive
Highland Mills, NY
Kathleen Higgins
76 Horatio St.4A
NY., NY
Stephen Moskovitz
55 West 55th. St.
New York, New York
Mary Bailey
825 West 187th Street, #4F
New York, NY
Arlene Fuccillo
92 La Bonne Vie Dr. Apt. C
Patchogue, New York
Robin Spiegelman
82-30 233 St
Queens Village, NY
Jeanette M. Brennan
8639 Canning Factory Road
Cassville, NY
Lauren Shapiro
1 pewter place
dix hills, ny
David Becking
31 Oakwood dr. N.
Englewood, Fla
William Kershaw
1753 St. Hway 41
Bainbridge, NY
Byron Connell
50 Dove Street
Albany, New York
Gloria Malter
235 Lincoln Place 4G
Brooklyn, New York
Emily Ickes
392 Brooktondale Rd
Brooktondale, NY
Lindsey Brooker
366 Western Ave P.O. Box #287
Albany, NY
David Stout
354 Lakeside Rd
Angola, NY
Lisa Jobson
P.O.B ox 57
Lake Hill, N.Y.
Mary Makepeace
175 South Main Street
Naples, N. Y.
Rick Gioia
167 Hudson St.
Cornwall on Hudson, NY
Lucinda Wilder
203 W Republican St
Seattle, WA
Geoff Wright
4736 Cleveland Rd
Syracuse, NY
Thomas Sandbichler
68 Hosking Lane
Accord, NY
Lynn Kenny
197 Ski Run Road
Bloomingburg, NY
Chris Decker
564 St. John Rd.
Afton, NY
Christopher Gautrau
12 Old Lantern road
New Milford, CT
Katja Lindskog
523 W112 Street
New York, NY
Dorothee Caulfield
25 Gordon Avenue
Briarcliff Manor, NY
Sally Vaughn
PO Box 224
Old Forge, New York
Robert Kozlowski
115 W.Groton Rd.
Groton, N.Y.
Ina Jeanne Salisbury
602 East Ave
Newark, NY
Katherine Denison
289 Rich's Dugway Road
Rochester, NY
Melba Arrington
300 Pelham Road, Apt 2-E
New Rochelle, NY
Lawrence Gallery
2882 River Road
Niskayuna, NY
Walter Piela
15 Hemlock La.
Albany, NY
Victor Romero
164-27 77th Avenue
Flushing, New York
m pappert
41 bedford street
ny, ny
Judith Gentleman
5445 Sayles Corners Rd.
Moravia, NY
Brenda Davis
31 Plains Road
Honoeye Falls, NY
Brandon Warner
3028 St. Hwy 205
Bainbridge, NY
Joseph Feliciano
4219 Natchez Trace Dr.
St. Cloud, FL
Bonnie Eisenberg
19 Green Meadows Lane
Loudonville, NY
christina ziegler
397 north little tor road
new city, ny
Emma Hartung
949 West End Avenue, Apt. #4B
New York, New York
Laurian Van Munster
126 Field St.
Rochester, NY
VIcky Brandt
28 W. 10th St.
New York, NY
Torben Russo
23 Hunter Lane
Ithaca, NY
bonnie berlinghof
227 east 50th street
nyc, ny
carole roseman
county 9
east chatham, ny
Donna Lightfoot
30 Sycamore Rd.
Rocky Point, NY
x baczewska
45 1st avenue
new york city, ny
mary weill
19 arosa ct
greenlawn, ny
Selma and Harold Brodbar
1615 Avenue I Apt 516
Brooklyn, New York
S. Doloff
333 East 14Street
New York, NY
Gustav Mergins
285 McKibben St
Brooklyn, NY
Jessie Rosenthal
55 South Lake Ave. Apt. B4
Albany, NY
Timothy Glaesemann
915 Wynnewood Road, Unit B2
Pelham, NY
Desirre Jones
708 West 171st Street
New York, NY
elizabeth Upton
176 East 3rd St, 4F
New York, New York
Cathy Huttner
19 Hydor Dr
Castleton, NY
L. Danielle Klock
322 South Geneva St.
Ithaca, NY
Pam Fishman
97 Sterling Place
BROOKLYN, NY
susan masters
p.o. box 97
panama, ny
Marcelle Crago
5 Viking Lane
Woodstock, New York
Daniel Murphy
472 41st Street
Brooklyn, NY
Karen Baum
1252 Ellis Hollow Rd.
Ithaca , NY
Jenny Walker
100 St Nicholas Ave
New York, NY
Laula Fritz
72 Barrow St.
New York, NY
Heidi Sheasby
pob 53
GLENFORD, NY
Joan Levine
100 La Salle St. #19F
New York, New York
Joe Stein
182-15 73rd Avenue
Fresh Meadows, nY
Ralph Krutulis, DC
4613 North Stret
Jamesville, New York
Robin Berson
80 La Salle St. #20F
New York, New York
E.M. Freeberg
3rd Place
Brooklyn, New York
Tina Mizhir
9 N Pearl St
Port Chester, NY
Paula Jones
Woodland Drive
CONESUS, NY
Hon. Anne Pratt Slatin
78 Main Street
Stamford, NY
Anne Mette Iversen
351 Van Brunt St, RH
Brooklyn, NY
Denise DeCesare
927 Irish Settlement Rd
Freeville, NY
PAMELA BREGENZER
11465 Mendoleine Road
Dansville, NY
karl neubauer
6028 state rte 53
prattsburgh, new york
Joan Gussow
563 Piermont Ave
Piermont, NY
Peter Schmidt
1 Sheridan St.
Glens Falls, NY
Julia Perce
229 Chestnut Hill Rd.
Woodstock, NY
Larry Rubin
639 East Lake Road
Penn Yan, New York
Mitchell Shapiro
1 pewter place
Dix hills, NY
kay ellen capo
520 W 110th St. Apt 2A
New York , New York
Nik Lokensgard
89 Vanderbilt Ave. #2
Brooklyn, NY
James Occhino
51 Winter Hill Road
Ghent, New York
Christina Mead, MS
306 Elm St.
Ithaca, NY
Jillian Evans
215 Bayberry Lane
Rochester, NY
Kaitlyn Lang
347 E 78 Street APT 3B
New York, NY
Kelly O'Donnell-Parsons
93 Union Ave
Lynbrook, NY
shana fuller
7507 Feather street
naples, NY
Eva DiDIa
60-23 69th Avenue
Ridgewood, NY
Stacey DiLauro
7782 Bainbridge Drive
Liverpool, NY
Stana Weisburd
75 Prospect Park West, #4B
Brooklyn, NY
Julia Raskin
PO 727
Hartsdale, NY
Chris Hernandez
98-19 64th Ave Apt 5A
Rego Park, NY
Ashlee Alamillo
17 Putnam St #1
ALBANY, NY New York
Sheila Driscoll RN
2105 West Genessee St.
Syracuse, NY
darlene benton
po box 28
albion, ny
RICK DRAGO
3605 13th St
Astoria, NY
Florence Gilchrist
3600 Fieldston Road
Bronx, NY
Seth Reisner
75-24 188th street
fresh meadows, ny
Katherine j Brewster
890 West End Ave., #4E
New York, NY

Pages